by Brian Ference | News
I have written before about the new Candace Czarny slate of Doug Drake, Janet Mohr, Tom Walsh, Liz Palmer, and Jack Swonson splitting the Republican Ticket of Cave Creek and Deer Valley School Boards by promoting 5 Republicans for 3 seats on their fake club Golden Ticket. That disastrous strategy was confirmed and instead of 3 Republicans in each school district easily winning the seats in two different school boards, 2 of the 3 seats in Cave Creek and 1 of the 3 seats in Deer Valley were won by liberal democrats who will continue to promote LGBTQ, trans bathrooms, DEI, and SEL among other democrat policies.
Cave Creek School Board Candidate Cody Reim had this to say about the vote-splitting: “I entered a race to gain a seat on the Cave Creek School Board. CCUSD has been in decline for at least the previous 4 years since the current board assumed office. Since 2020 there has been an almost 30% decline in student population. I made the choice to run on a slate with two fellow Republicans and amazing Patriots, Sheri Lopez & Stacey Goodman. The official LD3 leadership made the choice to endorse us three and place us on the LD3 Golden Ticket, We also were endorsed and placed on the AZ GOP Golden Ticket. Although we received tremendous support from many Republicans and the LD leadership, our race was negatively impacted by Candace Czarney’s LLC that is posing as LD3. Candace Czarney and her LLC made the choice to recommend 5 people for our race which only had 3 positions available. This caused a massive split in the Republican vote for us and the vote was split to two other candidates (one of which is an incumbent) not only did it cause our slate to not have a single one of us be elected, it caused the two most far left incumbents to be reelected. It is very disappointing and disheartening as a Young Republican, and first time running for an office, that a fellow “Republican” group would throw such an important race in our LD. I would hope that by the Mid-Terms in 2026 these underhanded actions can be ended and close races such as school board races can have some level of understanding that they will be supported by Republicans and PCs within our LD.”
This tragedy for our children lies directly at the feet of the new Candace Czarny slate of Doug Drake, Janet Mohr, Tom Walsh, Liz Palmer, and Jack Swonson. See their slate card below. Now Czarny has sent a fake election call letter for November 18th in Fountain Hills.
by Brian Ference | News
Several Candace Czarny Board Candidates are running for positions in LD3:
- Doug Drake
- Tom Walsh
- Janet Mohr
- Liz Palmer
Aside from donating to her fake club, whose members literally endorse Democrats and are helping to subvert and undermine the Republican Party like the most effective Democrat spies of all time, while engaging in repeated lawfare against true Republicans they also distribute fake Golden Tickets counter to the real LD3 Golden ticket which will split the vote and guarantee democrat school board members win. In the below photo, Doug Drake with name badge can clearly be seen distributing Czarny’s voter guide while claiming they are “LD3 GOP Voter Guides”.
The Real LD3 Golden Ticket DOES NOT split the vote and lists only three grass-roots Republican candidates for school board:
Their website and mailing list owner Rich Rutkowski is a Fountain Hills School Board Member and per https://www.fountainhillsrich.com/ “he has voted for every single spending item that has been presented by the superintendent and the board President. So, while Rich claims to be conservative, has sided every single time with the leftist members on spending and has been a rubber stamp for each and every reckless spending item. While schools are failing, losing enrollment, and needing to reign in budgets, he spends like a drunken frat boy on spring break.”
Czarny also lists Drake, Walsh, Mohr, and Parmer in her email newsletter as her “Electioneering Captains”:
by Brian Ference | News
In an article in Fountain Hills Times Independent dated October 1, 2024, Brenda Kalivianakis says ” It is my honor to serve the people of Fountain Hills as both a council member and as vice mayor. Many constituents have asked who I think is the best candidate for mayor. As a lifelong conservative, RNC election attorney and a Republican statewide and precinct committee member, I have always voted Republican. But as a council member elected to a nonpartisan office, it’s my duty to put party affiliation aside and vote for the best interests of the town, its businesses and all our citizens. For the past two years, I have worked with both mayoral candidates. In my opinion, the best-qualified is our incumbent mayor, Ginny Dickey.”
Brenda is was allegedly born a man John Kalivianakis and is now a Trans “woman”.
In the below video, Legislative District 3 Precinct Committeeman Brenda can be seen in the front row of a club meeting held by Candace Czary. Though somewhat blurred, Brenda is still clearly identifiable in the front row of Czarny’s private club meeting. Czarny has come under fire for impersonating an elected official, falsely claiming she is the “Official LD3 Chair” and engaging in campaign finance violations fundraising while impersonating a political party committee. Czarny is not recognized by either the State GOP, County GOP, and was forcibly removed from the County meeting by Police. Czarny has been suspended as a precinct committeeman for 2 years and none of her state delegates were accepted at the recent AZGOP State delegate meeting.
Brenda Kalivianakis Seen Front Row Right in Candace Czarny Meeting Impersonating LD3 Chair
The fake club whose members endorse Democrats is also supported by Arizona House of Representatives member Joseph Chaplik who is one of their largest donors. This raises questions if Joseph Chaplik himself is committing any campaign finance violations or other ethical violations.
by Brian Ference | News
On September 24, 2024, Legislative District 5 effectively suspended an LD5 Precinct Committeeman Gibson McKay for endorsing a Democrat, voting to “strip him of his role and privileges as a Precinct Committeeman within LD 5”. The document below was titled “CENSURE FOR THE REMOVAL OF PRECINCT COMMITTEEMAN GIBSON MCKAY” AZGOP MAL Jeremiah Cota posted the full resolution publicly on X stating “This is an aggressive move by a Legislative district to ask for an elected official to be stripped of status. County GOP passed bylaws in response to high profile Republicans endorsing Democrats in 2022 and 2020. Now bylaws being used to purge Republicans who go against party.”
The vote also stated the “LD 5 body formally requests the Maricopa County Republican Committee (MCRC) to take immediate action by holding a vote to remove Gibson McKay’s voting rights and his ability to serve in any official capacity within the MCRC.” (This would also strip McKay from voting rights at county-wide GOP meetings.)
Multiple other LD5 PCs also confirmed that the below verbiage was correct and was handed out at the LD5 meeting.
by Brian Ference | News
Today, America First Legal confirmed that Maricopa Recorder Stephen Richer is committing TREASON saying:
“Correct. Arizona has 42,301 voters on the federal voting rolls who could not or would not present proof of citizenship. On July 17, we sent demand letters to County Recorders in all 15 counties notifying them of their legal obligation under state law to screen existing voter rolls against federal databases in order to remove ineligible non-citizens. All 15 counties failed or declined to do so—which is also an open invitation for ineligible non-citizens to register in Arizona in the weeks to come. So we sued all 15 counties. We are suing ALL 15 counties in Arizona for refusing to remove illegals from their voter rolls. This follows our lawsuit against Maricopa. Every county in AZ is flagrantly defying its duty under state law to expunge illegal voters:”
Arizona Constitution Article II Section 28:
“Treason against the state shall consist only in levying war against the state, or adhering to its enemies, or in giving them aid and comfort. No person shall be convicted of treason unless on the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or confession in open court”
I am calling for Maricopa County Recorder Stephen Richer to be IMMEDIATELY placed under citizen arrest (or by any law officer in the state not in violation of their oath of office by refusing to act) and be tried for TREASON in a Grand Tribunal in light of the above irrefutable evidence.
by Brian Ference | News
“Republicans” Carrie Cox and Susan Wood continue to engage in lawfare against grassroot and legitimate Republicans just like democrats during the most critical election time. The two club members of Candace Czarny’s fake LD3 filed CV2024-021952 on August 13, 2024 requesting relief related to “legal power to call and preside“ over the upcoming Legislative District 3 Statutory Meeting to elect officers. This proves that the private club illegally impersonating LD3 while committing fraud and campaign finance violations always intended to file this lawsuit no matter what. Czarny also states in her club newsletter that is the reason for the lawsuit saying “2 Precinct Committeemen filed a case in Maricopa Superior Court to get an answer on who will be holding the LD3 Statutory Officer and State Committeeman election in 2024.“
Timothy La Sota, PLC was again the filing attorney for the plaintiffs. This is yet another example of “Republican” against Republican lawfare from La Sota and other attorneys in a series of losses. The Honorable Judge Frank W. Moskowitz ruled in case CV 2023-004799 that “It does not preclude political parties from holding other LD meetings and elections of officers, which may be necessary due to election contests, vacancies, or removals.” and “Here, the March election did not violate § 16-823.” and “IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED denying Plaintiff’s (Candace Czarny’s) claim for injunctive relief.”
In a related case funded by Czarny and her allies, The Honorable Judge Scott A. Blaney noted “THE COURT FINDS that Plaintiff was not candid with the Court in his sworn testimony. Plaintiff’s answers on cross-examination were evasive and lacked credibility, as did Plaintiff’s demeanor while testifying.“ and “Plaintiff’s lack of candor under oath greatly undermines his case.” The judge ruled in case CV 2024-008238 that “Plaintiff has failed to establish his entitlement to injunctive relief. Good cause shown, and in the Court’s discretion: IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED denying Plaintiff’s request for a preliminary injunction.”
This latest third filing was met with disgust by the Maricopa County GOP Chair saying “With only 66 days until the General Election, these Precinct Committeemen (Cox and Woods) have chosen to re-litigate a case that has already been brought by Candice Czarny, adjudicated by our courts, and ultimately delivered a victory to Maricopa County Republican Committee and the rightful LD3… It is clear that while we are focused on victory for President Donald Trump and our Republican candidates up and down the ballot, these Precinct Committeemen are focused on intra-party politics and titles that should reflect honor, hard work and servant leadership instead of the petty childish attention they are wishing to attain.” See the response to the frivolous lawsuit already once dismissed by a judge from the Maricopa GOP EGC:
AZGOP Allegedly Displeased with La Sota’s Lawfare Against Republicans
Despite using his services in the past under criminal Jeff Dewit, the AZGOP is allegedly quite displeased with La Sota’s lawfare against Republicans. According to an anonymous first-hand witness, AZGOP Chairwoman Gina Swoboda has communicated to her entire board that “As long as she is Chair, the AZGOP will no longer engage of the services of Mr. La Sota.”
Czarny is Suspended as a PC for 2 Years and Unable to Attend or Hold Elected Office:
- On December 14, 2023, the MCRC EGC suspended Candace Czarny from LD3 and the County Committee for a period of 24 months saying “Ms Czarny will no longer be recognized by either body nor have any interaction including but not limited to: attendance at county or district meetings, to hold an elected office, any voting rights or any other privileges granted as a precinct committeeman in Maricopa County.”
by Brian Ference | News
Contact the AZ Free Enterprise Club (602) 385-0757 info@azfree.org https://x.com/azfec and DEMAND they cancel speaking at fake ld3 which is not recognized by state, county, and is illegally impersonating a political organization and committing campaign finance violations: Speakers: Free Enterprise Club – April Smith, will be presenting the Propositions on the November Ballots. Fountain Hills, Cave Creek & Scottsdale School Board Candidates. Location: McDowell Mountain Community Center, 16116 N McDowell Mountain Ranch Rd, Scottsdale, AZ 85259 Time: 6:00 pm
by Brian Ference | News
Why do our elections continue to be stolen? Why are rapists and violent criminals released without bond? Why are violations of free speech, the 2nd amendment, and unalienable rights allowed to continue? Why is our border wide open with an invading army pouring through? Why is America being destroyed before our very eyes? Because bad actors are not held accountable with consequences.
I am disappointed in the LD3 Board withholding information and acting against the will of the body. At the July meeting, LD3 voted to suspend PCs who have not attended three consecutive meetings without providing an excuse. The full motion was: “Effective immediately and per the bylaws the body of LD3 will suspend all pcs on the board list who have not attended 3 consecutive meetings or provided a valid reason for absence AND email that list out to all pcs within 10 days (with number of consecutive meetings)”
It makes reference to our LD3 Bylaws ARTICLE III – MEMBERSHIP Section C. Duties 6. Attend all statutory and mandatory meetings of the District in person. Any PC missing three (3) or more consecutive regular district meetings, without prior notice to the EC, will meet with the Executive Committee, who will determine if the PC should be removed from office. The PC must be notified by the EC a minimum of ten (10) days, prior to the Executive Committee’s vote, to have a chance to respond. Removal from office shall require a majority vote by the Executive Committee. Removal shall constitute an immediate vacancy, which shall be submitted to the EGC per MCRC Bylaws.
It is well known that the removal of PCs in violation has not been completed by the Board. The Suspended list has not been released, and until today no communication was sent for nearly a month. This unfortunately demonstrates a lack of transparency.
Suspension was put forward as a viable alternative with significant precedent set:
- On December 14, 2023, the MCRC EGC suspended Candace Czarny from LD3 and the County Committee for a period of 24 months saying “Ms Czarny will no longer be recognized by either body nor have any interaction including but not limited to: attendance at county or district meetings, to hold an elected office, any voting rights or any other privileges granted as a precinct committeeman in Maricopa County.”
- On June 24, 2024, Legislative District 2 voted to suspend PC Christian Lamar, preventing him from attending meetings or voting saying a “recent vote by the Precinct Committeemen of LD2 to expel Christian Lamar from the LD2 business meetings effective immediately and to last at a minimum through October 31, 2024. At which time the newly elected PC’s can determine whether to end or extend the expulsion vote.”
- AZGOP Chair Gina Swoboda (who constantly consults with legal council) said of the matter on June 26th in a public tweet: “Christian Lamar is and remains the AZGOP member at large for CD8. The body of the precinct committeemen in LD2 have every right to take such actions as they deem appropriate at the LD level, however the MAL position falls under AZGOP and Mr Lamar remains in that position until the next officer elections’ – Gina Swoboda, Chair https://x.com/AZGOP/status/1806187134497550438
Arizona Law and Roberts Rules of Order Support It:
A.R.S. 38-291 Vacancy Defined https://www.azleg.gov/ars/38/00291.htm
An office shall be deemed vacant from and after the occurrence of any of the following events before the expiration of a term of office:
1. Death of the person holding the office.
2. Insanity of the person holding the office, when judicially determined.
3. Resignation of the person holding the office and the lawful acceptance of the resignation.
4. Removal from office of the person holding the office, including the removal of a board or commission member by the appointing power before the expiration of the person’s term of office.
5. If the office is elective, the person holding the office ceasing to be a resident of the state, or, if the office is local, or from a legislative or congressional district, the person holding the office ceasing to be a resident of the district, county, city, town or precinct for which the person was elected, or within which the duties of the person’s office are required to be discharged.
6. Absence from the state by the person holding the office, without permission of the legislature, beyond the period of three consecutive months.
7. The person holding the office ceasing to discharge the duties of office for the period of three consecutive months.
8. Conviction of the person holding the office of a felony or an offense involving a violation of the person’s official duties.
9. Failure of the person elected or appointed to the office to file the person’s official oath within the time prescribed by law.
10. A decision of a competent tribunal declaring void the election or appointment of the person elected or appointed to the office.
11. Failure of a person to be elected or appointed to the office.
12. A violation of section 38-296 by the person holding the office.
RONR 61:6 Principles Governing Discipline at Meetings. A society has the right to determine who may be present at its meetings and to control its hall while meetings are in progress; but all members have the right to attend except in cases where the bylaws provide for the automatic suspension of members who fall in arrears in payment of their dues, or where the society has, by vote and as a penalty imposed for a specific offense, forbidden attendance.
Making Decisions Based on Fear or False Legal Interpretations
After Czarny and Lamar were suspended, neither one sued. Czarny’s original lawsuit requesting injunctive relief was denied. The only reason it was even heard instead of being dismissed immediately was because corrupt Jeff Dewit begged the judge to hear it and illegally payed all the legal fees from AZGOP funds. It was eventually dismissed because the court has a long standing precedent of not ruling on inter-party conflicts.
The LD3 Chairman states in a recent email “we have been tracking a current lawsuit brought against the MCRC and Board of Supervisors regarding removal of precinct committeemen”. The current issue is suspension and any litigation on removal (which the judge will most certainly dismiss based on precedent) has no bearing whatsoever on suspension.
The hard truth is that certain members of the board do not want the prescribed consequences for the bad actors of LD3. This acting against the will of the body and refusal to enforce consequences is exactly like the behavior we have seen of the weak Congress, with Republicans voting against even censure or any penalties for Alejandro Mayorkas United States Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security. The MCRC on Tuesday censured and disciplined 6 alternate delegates who brought fake challenges without merit, and 40 Republicans publicly supporting Kamala Harris and Ruben Gallego. It is time for the LD3 to follow this example and hold bad actors accountable. On Tuesday I will introduce a motion which clarifies any open questions on suspension including defining it as well as methods of unsuspension once violators come back into compliance. I encourage all to support this motion and demand that the LD3 Board enforce consequences and demand they release the list of suspended PCs. Please contact other PCs and ask that they attend Tuesday’s meeting and support the motion.
by Brian Ference | News
UPDATE: Following a one-sided report by FOX News, it is important to note their story ignored that the LD14 Chairman is required to de-escalate any issues with members and follow certain procedures prior to removing a member from the hall. Further, Adams violated their own bylaws:
Subsection 5. Disciplinary Action 1. Any disciplinary action imposed by the District requires a 2/3 vote of the PCs present in person or by proxy and voting.
DECORUM – Roberts Rules of Order 12th Edition: #61:15 The case may be sufficiently resolved by an apology or a withdrawal of objectionable statements or remarks by the offender; #61:11 Calling a member to order. “-as when a member repeatedly questions the motives of other members whom he mentions by name…” “-the chair normally should first warn the member; but with or without such a warning, the chair or any other member can “call the member to order.”, #61:12 Naming an offender REMOVAL FROM THE HALL #61:13 Although the chair has no authority to impose a penalty or to order the offending member removed from the hall, the assembly has that power. #61:16 The offending member can be required to leave the hall during the consideration of his penalty, but he must be allowed to present his defense briefly first. A motion to require the member’s departure during consideration of the penalty- which may be assumed by the chair if he things it appropriate- is undebatable, is unamendable, and requires a majority vote.
Adams did not follow any of the rules or procedures, did not call for a vote for removal, and instead of de-escalating the situation, inflamed and escalated it directly causing the situation caught on tape.
On Monday, July 15, 2024, the Legislative District 14 Chair Andrew Adams was involved in an incident outside the LD14 Meeting. See the below security video which clearly shows Adams in the white/silver shirt and jeans, pointing in the face of several people and acting as the LARGEST and most aggressive physical presence. The alleged attacker in the black shirt is significantly shorter than Adams and has to stand up on tiptoes to even near eye level. After the incident, Adams aggressively pursues him and others. Is this the behavior of an assault victim? Adams has a history of attempting to physically intimidate people in dark alleys, and a pattern of intimidating women, while aggressively censoring any free speech or criticism, and a dark past as a convicted drug dealer.
Adams claims he was assaulted and improperly plays the victim while comparing himself to the Donald Trump assassination saying in a statement:
“Lalani Hunsaker’s Nathan, stood on his tiptoes, said “F you” to me, and then headbutted me. His friend recorded the incident, and the police have been notified. With the attempted assassination of President Trump, the notion that someone identifying as a Republican would resort to violence at our meeting must be condemned in the strongest terms. My daughter was present at the meeting tonight.”
Lalani Hunsaker responded saying:
“This is a complete misrepresentation of the events of this evening. Laurin Hendrix mentioned my son during his “legislative update.” I stood up and asked him to stop. As a mother; I had every right to stand up and defend my child against the slanderous and defamatory accusations alleged by Laurin Hendrix. Unfortunately rather than stopping Laurin; Andrew Adams began yelling at me to sit down. My brother in law who had been invited to the meeting by another PC came to my and my son’s defense by standing up and telling Laurin to stop. It is neglect by Andrew Adams as the Chair of LD14 to allow a political hit against another Republican during an LD meeting. It is gross negligence on the part of the Chair, as he was completely inept at keeping order during the meeting. This political character assault likely was orchestrated and colluded by Andrew Adams and Laurin Hendrix. And is continuing in this fabricated post. Furthermore, my husband did not head but Andrew Adams. That is physically impossible. Andrew was yelling in Nate’s face and Andrew is 6 inches taller than my husband. Nate went on his tiptoes to look Andrew in the eye when Andrew was screaming at him. Nate never said F you. The whole incident is recorded. And video was viewed by the police. No arrests were made and no official report was filled. Finally, I was never given the opportunity to refute the heinous claims that Laurin Hendrix perpetrated and I remained in the meeting until it concluded in hopes of having that opportunity. The ineptitude exhibited tonight at the LD meeting was ridiculous and the fact that Andrew Adams allowed this to happen is reprehensible.”
Adams claims a report was filed and he will be obtaining a restraining order and have banned multiple people from the meeting. This is despite Andrew Adams criticizing a restraining order against his good friend Dan Farley who assaulted a County Member at Large on security camera, striking him in the chest. Unlike with Adams who was acting aggressively, the victim of the below video in the red shirt had his hands behind his back calmly speaking before being struck by Adams friend Farley. Adams referred to the victim of that assault as “not being a man” and falsely accusing the victim of “setting Dan up” see the below video:
Representative David Cook got in on playing victim and spreading false information as well saying in a public post on X that allowed no comments: “This morning I have been informed that Laurin Hendrix AZ State House Representative was almost assaulted (this is curious, what exactly is an “almost assault”?) at a local district meeting in Gilbert last night while speaking to his constituents. The police were called, the chairman of the group intervened and was assaulted. Evidence was seized by the local police. It should be clear after the incident involving President Trump and the victims this past week that in no cases should violence be tolerated regarding political events of any kind.” Cook should be condemning Adams. It is outrageous to compare the events in the Adams video above to an attempted assassination attempt where one audience member was killed and others injured including Donald Trump who was shot in the ear and had he not turned his head would have been killed by a bullet passing through his brain. Cook and Adams should be ashamed and both resign.
by Brian Ference | News
In an exclusive story, uncontested Republican Primary LD2 Candidate Ari Bradshaw has been accused of previously “selling cocaine and psychedelics” as well as an allegation of selling fentanyl. A series of text messages (warning obscene language) alleging the crime happened in the past when Bradshaw was in college or before. The timing of these events match up with an October 12, 2016 drug arrest of Bradshaw for Marijuana (case number seen at bottom of post).
Bradshaw was also publicly accused of being a “Former drug dealer” by Arizona Young Republican National Committeeman Luke Mosiman (archived link):
Bradshaw responded to my questions saying “I have never seen fentanyl in my life. I will be sending a defamation lawsuit your way.” After explaining to him that I was merely seeking comment on the allegations clearly made by another in a tweet here, and then explaining the burden of proof for defamation and the Arizona Constitution, Bradshaw seemed to backtrack from his legal threats and continued answering questions saying:
“Never was arrested with intent to distribute weed. My father died of suicide following a legal opioid addiction and my cousin died of heroin later on.”
Bradshaw also made several public statements regarding the allegations, including in a public reply to embattled Senator and frequent First Amendment Violator, Wendy Rogers seen at the bottom of this post.
It is ironic to note that Bradshaw recently leaked a phone conversation between himself and Rogers, accusing Rogers of defending candidate Steve Slaton for allegedly using the “N-word” when describing a black Republican Representative. If that wasn’t enough Irony, Ari produced music for explicit lyrics including the “N-word” and then promoted the single apparently very proud of the lyrics saying “STREAM IT NOW! IT’S A BOP” (warning explicit lyrics below)
