by Brian Ference | News
On Thurday night, LD3 had a “Vote of NO CONFIDENCE” in Candace Czarny and demanded her immediate resignation. The vote passed with majority 92 Yes votes and 51 No votes.
This came after new revelations in the Treasurer’s report which called out Candace’s unapproved spending (including huge amounts on unnecessary police) with no approved budget (a requirement of the bylaws) and having violated the Bylaws multiple times including REMOVING THE TREASURER from the bank accounts. Earlier in the evening, Candace ejected Maricopa 1st Vice Chair Shelby Bush from the meeting.
Resigning should prove easy for Candace, as after another disorganized and terrible start to the meeting, she abdicated the running of the meeting to hired gun Parliamentarian Dan Grimm, appointing him Chair for the evening.
*Note the Treasurer has since been re-added, but is calling for a full audit.
by Brian Ference | News
Many have seen the video of LD3 Candace Czarny ruling everything under the sun Out of Order. The below references from Roberts Rules of Order 12th Edition prove Candace was in Flagrant Violation the entire time:
PROXIES
Proxy Votes are NOT counted in a voice vote or rising vote as was modeled at the State Committeeman meeting. This specific question was asked and proxy votes are not counted in this type of vote.
#45:2 One Person, One Vote. It is a fundamental principle of parliamentary law that each person who is a member of a deliberative assembly is entitled to one-and only one- vote on a question.
#45:56 Absentee Voting. It is a fundamental Principle of parliamentary law that the right to vote is limited to the members of an organization who are actually present at the time the vote is taken in a regular or properly called meeting…
45:70 Proxy Voting. A proxy is a power of attorney given by one person to another to vote in his stead; the term also designates the person who holds the power of attorney. Proxy voting is not permitted in ordinary deliberative assemblies unless the laws of the state in which the society is incorporated require it, or the charter or bylaws of the organization provide for it. Ordinarily it should neither be allowed nor required, because proxy voting is incompatible with the essential characteristics of a deliberative assembly…
OBTAINING AND ASSIGNING THE FLOOR
#3:30 Before a member in an assembly can make a motion or speak in debate-the parliamentary name given to any form of discussion of the merits of a motion-he must obtain the floor, that is he must be recognized by the chair as having the exclusive rights to be heard at that time. The chair must recognize any member who seeks the floor while entitled to it.
MOTIONS WHICH ARE IN ORDER WHEN ANOTHER HAS THE FLOOR AND DO NOT REQUIRE A SECOND
t44-t45
- Parliamentary Inquiry 33:3-5
- Point of Order 23
- Request for Information 33:6-10
OUT OF ORDER
#4:17 When a member who has legitimately obtained the floor offers a motion which is not in order, the chair may be able, in certain instances, to suggest an alternative motion which would be in order and would carry out the desired intent to the satisfaction of the maker. If the chair is obliged to rule that the motion is not in order, he says, “The chair rules that the motion is not in order because [briefly stating the reason] He must not say “You are out of order,” nor, “Your motion is out of order.” To state that a member is out of order implies that the member is guilty of a breach of decorum or other misconduct; and even in such a case, the chair does not normally address the member in the second person. If the chair rules that a motion is not in order, his decision is subject to an appeal of the judgement of the assembly.
APPEAL
#24:1 By electing a presiding officer, the assembly delegates to him the authority and duty to make necessary rulings on questions of parliamentary law. But any two members have the right to Appeal from his decision on such a question. By one member making the appeal and another seconding it, the question is taken from the chair and vested in the assembly for final decision.
by Brian Ference | News
Brian Ference responds to misleading questions from anonymous PCs in Republican Briefs (Please do not edit my words)
Frosty, I would appreciate being given the same courtesy as a MAL elected by over 2000+ PCs that you admitted to extending to Candace Czarny who was allegedly elected by a mere 200+ PCs in LD3. To do otherwise seems to be clear favoritism and bias.
To the anonymous PCs who seem to fear the words and light of truth exposing dark deeds above all. I would remind you that words are not violence and even when I was physically assaulted by LD4 Chair Dan Farley, I still did not raise a hand to him. If the truth makes you fear for your safety so much, I suggest you immediately flee to CHYNA!
by Brian Ference | News
The below email was provided by an anonymous whistleblower and was sent by LD3 Secretary Jamie Alford to then County Chair Mickie Niland on Sunday, December 4, 2022 at 9:13pm indicating a UNANIMOUS decision by all LD3 Board members “Including a canvass or verification of proxies...”. Candace Czarny has subsequently blocked this from being performed for 2 months. Is this because Candace knows the chain of custody with the proxies was broken? Will an audit and canvas reveal that proxies were carried by PCs outside of the same precincts which is a violation of the rules and bylaws? Are the seals on the envelope still intact, or have the proxies been tampered with?
See the email below:
by Brian Ference | News
UPDATE: Below is added a Written Statement who witnessed the proxy fraud in LD3 including filling out of fraudulent proxies outside the door.
New evidence has emerged from Legislative District 3 indicating PROXY FRAUD and ELECTION FRAUD.
In the below email sent on November 21, 2022 at 12:14 pm, Brad Newman, Granite Mountain PC Captain and Leader of the Desert Mountain Breakfast Club specifically instructs PCs to “COMPLETE ONLY THE HIGHLIGHTED SECTIONS” and “By not completing the assignment section it will be easier for us (to) match up your form with people.” These instructions and the highlighted form (also below) which Brad attached, clearly instructs PCs to sign with their signature but not designate an appointee. (Several PCs with decades of experience expressed shock that a PC Captain would give these instructions.) Then later, someone else would fill in the name on that proxy form. This invalidates the proxy per statute.
There are reports these proxy forms were later filled out by PCs waiting in line to get into the December 1st meeting with “organizers” or “proxy mules” having stacks of them to fill out just that section. This is PROXY FRAUD.
These proxies were then used in the December 1st LD3 Election to the benefit of Candace Czarny. THIS IS ELECTION FRAUD.
Remember that the County already conducted an investigation finding multiple rule and bylaws violations due to ballot handoffs etc and voted for a new election recommendation similar to LD11. The official minutes confirm the accuracy and validity of the recording of the motion. Proxy Parties were held in advance in a coordinated effort by Nancy Ordowski, Cathy Schwanke, and others who were very outspoken and sent emails indicating their support of Candace. Cathy Schwanke was also the Credentials and Tally Chair, and accepted ballots at the ballot box. She was personally involved in several of the documented ballot handoff violations.
At the December 1st Meeting, Sherry Gavin was checking in proxies, and according to an eye witness PC, did not know that she had to invalidate a proxy that wasn’t being carried by a PC in their same precinct. She called former Chair Rich over to the table and told him she needed to VOID it as invalid. Rich looked up, saw the eye witness, and then instructed her to do so for the one proxy. How many proxies from outside their precinct were not invalidated?
92 Proxies were used at the December 1st meeting. The board voted unanimously to audit and canvas the proxies and it was mentioned in the MCRC recording/vote here. Yet since then Candace has stubbornly blocked it. Why? Would a proxy audit and canvas reveal that many of the proxies used were invalid? Would it reveal that the chain of custody was broken for 2 days after the election? Would it reveal that proxies were fraudulently carried by pcs in different precincts?
An immediate new election for LD3 Board must be called. A full audit and canvas of the proxies in light of this PROXY FRAUD and ELECTION FRAUD must be completed immediately.
The Proxy fraud was then admitted to publicly in Republican Briefs by a PC stating they had been doing it for 14 years:
JEANNIE MCGILL: The unfortunate tone of Brian Ference’s comments on fraud have given me the urge to write this response. Granite Mountain Precinct has been an outstanding precinct. We have maintained a healthy forum for discussion, know each other and their spouses, give 100% of recommended contributions and always deliver good solid Republican turnout. I was the first/only Captain of the precinct for the last 12-14 years. When some of our PCs could not make a meeting where voting was taking place, I encouraged them to be a proxy vote. Since one is never sure who is going to the meeting until the last minute, putting a proxy carrier name on the proxy was done at the last minute. In my 14 years, I never had anyone designate who they wanted for their carrier. Ference has put a twist on this scenario with words like “evidence” and “proxy and election fraud”. Those are words Adam Schiff would use! Ference had a copy of Brad Newman’s email to his PCs. The sentence was “Unless you have a specific person to whom you want to assign your proxy, please COMPLETE ONLY THE HIGHLIGHTED SECTIONS. By not completing the assignment section, it will make it easier for us to match up your form with people who will be attending the meeting in person.” You have to be specific so that your PCs don’t goof up the form. Captains know this. How many captains see this as some kind of fraud? Ference later in his “evidence letter” wrote that Brad “clearly instructs PCs to sign with their signature but not designate an appointee.” Please compare what was written and how it was distorted. I find this fraudulent, misleading and with the intention to deceive. Is it Ference intent to be disruptive, divisive and sow discontent in our new LD which is struggling to get find its mojo. The main focus is to build unity and fight the real enemy, not each other. Brad Newman, who now leads our precinct and educates our area with the Breakfast Club, deserves praises and not a character assassination from a fellow Republican.
(PCs and LD Chairs in other LDs, you must work to eliminate proxies. The convenience is not worth the documented fraud being used to steal elections)
by Brian Ference | News
Dan Farley, candidate for AZGOP State Chair, has sent emails (publicly posted in Republican Briefs) defending the FBI, Maricopa Recorder Stephen Richer, and MCBOS Chairman Bill Gates, saying:
“What did passing this censure accomplish? Has Richer resigned? What if he did, then where would we be?” and “Richer is providing us more information at MCRC than he is required to. Is the best timing to do something like this now?”
Meanwhile Stephen Richer continues to push Ranked Choice Voting statewide. The clear sabotage of printers in only Republican areas under Richer and Gates in the 2022 General election and the release of “The Twitter Files” proves both the Richer and Gates censures and the Maricopa LD3 Censure of the FBI in August was absolutely correct and lead the way with courage and integrity despite massive backlash from Dan Farley.
Much more evidence is available at https://realdanfarley.com/ including an audio leak of Dan Farley’s racist rant against Muslims, how he really feels about The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and security video footage of Dan Farley’s unprovoked physical assault on a Republican MCRC MAL. The Maricopa County Republican Committee has since passed a ZERO TOLERANCE policy of physical assault by members.
Instead of apologizing or admitting any fault, Dan Farley has continued to gaslight everyone, spinning lies about how he supports love and cooperation, conflating facts with unrelated events and groups, and building a hypocritical campaign all around “bullying“. A cease and desist letter, police report, security video, and dozens of email and social media attacks from Dan reveal the irrefutable evidence that Dan Farley is the biggest bully of them all.
View Dan Farley’s Email Below from 10/7/22 Saying He Thinks 1/3 of Republicans are Money Grubbers, 1/3 are Nazis:
by Brian Ference | News
UPDATE: I have just learned that the contract has been modified and firearms will now be allowed!
Several PCs have raised their concerns about the supposed “no firearms” rule coming from the contract that the Maricopa County Chair has signed with Dream City Church for the January 14th Statutory Meeting. They were so concerned that they contacted Dream City Church:
“I contacted someone that works for the head executive pastor at Dream City church. They confirmed with their lawyer and risk management team which also includes the executive team that they are 2A supporters and have not changed their concealed carry rules. They said if a third party is requesting that you not carry that is their request not Dream Cities.”
Also
“There’s a good reason also why they would not change their policy because many on the staff conceal and carry for their own protection because they get many death threats. That is also information I received this morning.”
The question arises, who requested adding no firearms to the contract?
The Maricopa County Chair appears not to know, stating “it was written in the contract when I received it”.
So we don’t know where this violation of PCs Constitutional Rights came from, but apparently not Dream City Church. I call on the County Chair to immediately contact Dream City Church and request where that line came from and if it can be removed.
The County Chair then had her lawyer send a threatening email which appears to grossly misinterpret Arizona Law and the 2nd Amendment.
by Brian Ference | News
LD11 had their revote last night (12/27) and re-elected a new Board and State Committeemen. They even had one PC participate live from Canada. Notice this revote was not called “unfair” or “illegal” and didn’t receive threats and coercion from the Maricopa County Chair like LD3 did.
From Mickie Niland on December 19th:
“Therefore, I am giving this LD Leadership team one more opportunity to show that they can act as their oath of office states “Fair and Impartial in the discharge of their duties. ” In my view their action calling for an election on December 28th casts doubt on the stated goal of having a free and fair election. IF, note the IF, they do not call for another election after the holidays. I will tell Chairman Ward that I approve the presently existing list of State Committeeman which I submitted to them on December 14th along with all the other LD’s State Committeeman lists.”
One PC described the threats from Mickie Niland toward the LD3 board similar to how Katie Hobbs threatened the Cochise County Board of Supervisors.
Mickie falsely stated in an email “Unlike the LD11 where both were challenged. So luckily for you, you are only voting to see if your SC election will be redone or if the existing election stands. Nothing more.”
Yet an anonymous whistleblower has provided an audio recording of the MCRC Executive board vote after its investigation which says: “A motion to ask them to do the same thing we are asking LD11 do…a motion have them conduct their election the same as LD11…we recommend that LD3 convene and decide whether to have a new election…” This vote carried 8-2 and there was NO MENTION of State Committeeman Only.
Listen to the audio here: https://odysee.com/@videouploads:b/ld3motion:4
Another PC posted these details proving the 12/28 meeting was correctly called and noticed with full authority and consequence:
FACT: 12/17/22 LD3 board meeting was called by three members of the board according to our bylaws.
FACT: That board meeting was ATTENDED by ALL FIVE board members (indicating proper notice and invitation).
FACT: Chair Czarny officially presided at the meeting AND CALLED THE MEETING TO ORDER!
(Now why would she do that if the meeting was invalid?)
FACT: Chair Czarny and Sec Alford BOTH participated in voting in that meeting!
(Again, why would they do that if the meeting was invalid?)
FACT: Official meeting call notice was sent out according to our bylaws
It looks Mickie Niland is the one who is in violation of her oath of office and is acting neither fairly, impartially, or honestly.
Email images below:
by Brian Ference | News
PSALMS 58
God’s justice? You high and mighty politicians
know nothing about it!
Which one of you has walked in justice toward others?
Which one of you has treated everyone right and fair?
Not one! You only give “justice” in exchange for a bribe.
For the right price you let others get away with murder.
Wicked wanderers even from the womb—that’s who you are!
You lie with your words, and your teaching is poison.
Like cobras closing their ears to the most expert of the charmers,
you strike out against all who are near.
O God, break their fangs;
shatter the teeth of these ravenous lions!
Let them disappear like water falling on thirsty ground.
Let all their weapons be useless.
Let them be like snails dissolving into the slime.
Let them be cut off, never seeing the light of day!
God will sweep them away so fast
that they’ll never know what hit them.
The godly will celebrate in the triumph of good over evil,
and the lovers of God will trample
the wickedness of the wicked under their feet!
Then everyone will say, “There is a God who judges the judges”
and “There is a great reward in loving God!”
by Brian Ference | News
The 4th Peaceful Protest in the #AZREVOTE movement completed Saturday with ZERO violence. This has officially set a precedent for peaceful protest. In future protests, any violence will CLEARLY be from FED Infiltrators trying for a false flag or from outside Antifa/Leftist groups as the Patriots in Arizona are demonstrably and repeatedly peaceful. At one point a Native American Group joined with the Peaceful Patriots.
Stop being afraid and sacrificing your 1st Amendment Rights! Stand Up to Peacefully Assemble and Petition the Government for a Redress of Grievances! YOU must show up for the County Certification meeting Monday, November 28, 2022 7:30am. 301 W Jefferson, 10th Floor Phoenix, AZ 85003
View the Image Gallery Below:
The first protest drove by the MCBOS office peacefully without trespassing or breaking any laws. Continue to pass by in your cars, but also show up on foot with signs on public property and designated protest areas etc to make your voice peaceably heard. Here is a letter from all the Republican Party County Chairman throughout Arizona to our Maricopa County Board of Supervisors, unitedly standing against certification of our November 8, 2022 General Election
Chair members and representatives from Arizona’s 15 counties, and Arizona GOP Chairwoman Kelli Ward, registered their objections to election certification “until such time as the many issues related to the administration of the 2022 General Election are thoroughly investigated, and the potential statutory violations of A.R.S Title 16 are remedied.”
In Person: To make general comments during “Call to the Public” OR speak on an agenda Item, you must fill out a speaker form at the meeting and turn it in to the Clerk’s staff.
Written: To leave comments for the Board of Supervisors, please send them to agenda.comments@maricopa.gov.
Virtual: To speak on a Planning and Zoning Hearing or Statutory Hearing Item virtually, submit speaker form posted at below site: English or Spanish. You must submit your speaker form before 8 am on meeting day.
When: Monday, November 28, 2022 8:00 am Board of Supervisors Special/Executive Meeting
Where: 301 W Jefferson, 10th Floor Phoenix, AZ 85003
Residents may submit comments related to the Board Informal Meeting agenda before 7:30 am on Monday, November 28th by emailing Agenda.Comments@Maricopa.Gov or calling (602) 506-3766.
Residents may watch the Board meeting live-streamed at Maricopa.Gov or Maricopa.Gov/324 at the time of the meeting.
Residents may also watch via GoToWebinar.com, and enter the webinar meeting ID 929-337-331. Pre-registration may be done via this link: https://attendee.gotowebinar.com/register/956352342581568781
Residents may listen to the Webinar by dialing +1 ((562) 247-8422 and enter the Audio Access code 475-030-253#. Long distance charges may apply.
No Audio PIN is needed to listen only.
If speaking virtually on a hearing item, desktop computer access is best. Cell phones must have webinar application downloaded to participate.
More Information: https://www.maricopa.gov/324/Board-of-Supervisors-Meeting-Information
Join the #AZREVOTE Telegram: https://t.me/+mu_ygAdp-Q41OTlh
